Holiday dupes: Love Santorini? Try these Greek Island alternatives
It’s not hard to see why Santorini gets so much of the Greek island limelight. Whitewashed villages, blue-domed churches and sunsets over the Aegean are all part of its iconic appeal. But its popularity can come with a price tag to match, particularly if you’re looking during the busy summer months.
The good news? Santorini might be one of Greece's best-known islands, but there’s a whole lot more to discover beyond those famous views. From the pretty villages of Paros to the long sandy shores of Naxos, there are plenty more Greek islands worth getting to know.
They aren't exact copies, and they won't necessarily be cheaper every time. But the right island could give you more of what matters, whether that’s more beach, more space or simply more holiday for your budget.
Here are five Santorini alternatives worth having on your radar…
Find your Santorini alternative
Not sure which island to start with? Think about what you love most about Santorini, then use our quick cheat sheet to narrow it down:
For whitewashed villages and stylish evenings – try Paros
For sandy beaches and laidback days – try Naxos
For dramatic landscapes – try Milos
For lots of variety in one trip – try Crete
For beaches mixed with sightseeing – try Rhodes
Now, let’s take a closer look at what each island has to offer.
1. Paros – best for whitewashed villages
For winding streets and laidback evenings, Paros deserves a spot on your shortlist. You'll still find the classic Cycladic mix of whitewashed buildings and blue details, while the fishing village of Naoussa adds a pretty harbour, restaurants and no shortage of places for an evening drink.
Golden beaches add another side to Paros, too, so your days don't have to be all wandering and photo stops. Unlike Santorini, you don’t have to build your whole holiday around getting that iconic view. There’s more freedom to choose where you base yourself and still dip into the island’s villages, beaches and restaurants as you go.
Paros has become increasingly popular, so it isn’t a secret bargain island. It’s worth pricing up both for your dates and seeing what you actually get for your money. It comes down to where you'd rather spend more, whether that's on your hotel, location or experiences, rather than automatically paying extra for Santorini’s caldera view.
Value tip – Staying elsewhere on Paros doesn’t mean missing out on Naoussa. Compare accommodation in other parts of the island and factor in the cost of getting there for an afternoon or evening. A cheaper hotel only makes sense if travel costs don’t eat up the saving.
2. Naxos – best for long sandy beaches
Long, sandy beaches, waterfront tavernas and plenty of time by the sea put Naxos firmly on the map for a classic Greek beach holiday.
Here, you’re swapping Santorini’s dramatic caldera setting for a lot more sand. Agios Prokopios is one of the island’s best-known beaches, while Naxos Town brings an Old Town and plenty of authentic restaurants into the mix when you fancy a break from your sunlounger.
That can make a difference to where you choose to spend your money, too. If being close to a sandy beach matters more than waking up to a caldera view, you can choose your hotel with that in mind. You’ll still get that Greek island character, with swims, beach days and plenty of exploring thrown in.
Value tip – Naxos has miles of beach to choose from, so don’t automatically pay more to stay right on the sand. Staying a short walk away could open up more hotel options without taking easy beach days off the table.
3. Milos – best for dramatic volcanic scenery
Milos is the wildcard of the five, and that’s exactly what makes it interesting. Both islands owe much of their drama to their volcanic landscapes, but the end result is completely different. While Santorini has its caldera and blue domes, Milos has Sarakiniko Beach, where smooth white rock meets bright blue sea.
So, this isn’t a cheaper version of Oia, and it isn’t trying to be. If it’s the wow-factor scenery you love about Santorini, Milos gives you something just as memorable in its own way.
The way you spend your money can look a little different here, too. In Santorini, the view itself can be part of where you stay, whereas on Milos much of the appeal comes from getting out and discovering the coastline, beaches and fishing villages for yourself.
Value tip – Work out how much time you'll actually spend at your hotel before you book. A simpler base could free up some of your budget for getting around and seeing the island.
4. Crete – best for a trip with more variety
Santorini’s compact size can be part of its appeal, but Crete goes in completely the opposite direction. With far more ground to cover, there’s plenty to keep you busy throughout your stay, whether you're in the mood for exploring or doing very little by the sea.
Around Chania, pretty harbour evenings sit alongside beach days, traditional villages and trips further into the island. Rather than sticking to one type of day, you can change the pace as you go.
All that choice makes it easier to shape the holiday around your budget. With different resorts, hotel styles and board bases to choose from, you can focus your spend on the things that matter most to you.
Value tip – Compare board bases as well as hotels. Bed and Breakfast could suit a trip built around meals out and exploring, while Half Board or All Inclusive could earn its keep when you’re planning plenty of easy hotel and beach days.
5. Rhodes – best for beaches and sightseeing
Can’t decide between sightseeing and switching off? Rhodes makes room for both. Spend one day exploring the Medieval streets of Rhodes Old Town, another by the sea, then slow everything down with a day at your resort.
And that’s where Rhodes really comes into its own. Sightseeing, beach days and proper downtime can all fit into the same trip. That mix can work particularly well for family holidays or groups where everyone's idea of a great holiday looks a little different.
The right hotel matters, too. Planning to spend most days out exploring? You might not need a long list of facilities. If plenty of downtime is on the agenda, a good pool or the right board basis could suit your trip better.
Value tip – Decide what you actually want to see before choosing your resort. Paying a little more for the right location could save you time and travel costs once you're there.
Make your Greek island holiday go further
Found a couple of islands you'd happily swap Santorini for? Good news, choosing where you go is only the start. A few smart choices around when you travel and what you book could help your holiday money work even harder.
Travel outside the summer peak
When you travel can be just as important as where you go. Travelling outside the school holidays gives you more dates to play with, so compare options either side of the July and August peak. May, June, September and October can be good places to start your search for better value.
And don’t just check whether the same holiday becomes cheaper. Keep your budget the same and you might find an upgraded room, a higher-rated hotel or a location you’d previously ruled out comes within reach. Just remember that weather, opening times and atmosphere can vary outside peak season, so weigh any saving against what matters most to you.
Know which extras you'll actually use
Two hotels can give you very different things for your money, even when they cost around the same. Before you book, look at what you're paying for and ask yourself how much of it you'll actually use.
A hotel with loads of facilities isn't automatically better value if you'll spend every day at the beach or out exploring. When your holiday is more about pool days, hotel drinks and easy meals, paying more for the right facilities or board basis could make sense.
The aim isn't to squeeze the price as low as possible. It's to spend your budget on the parts of the holiday you'll actually enjoy.
Find your Greek island match
Santorini might be the island that first caught your eye, but it doesn’t have to be where the search ends. From Paros’ village charm to Naxos’ sandy beaches and Rhodes’ mix of sightseeing and downtime, looking beyond the obvious could uncover a Greek island that suits your holiday even better.
The trick is to work out what you’re really hoping to get from your time away. Maybe it’s the Cycladic scenery that drew you to Santorini, or perhaps you’d happily swap the famous views for longer beach days, more places to explore or more choice over where your money goes. Once you know what matters most, it becomes much easier to compare your options.
And that’s what great value is really about – not simply spending less but spending on the holiday you actually want.
Found your Santorini dupe? Explore our Greece holiday deals to see where your budget could take you, or head to our Sundeals blog for more destination dupes, travel hacks and straight-talking tips for finding great-value holidays.
Author: Rachel Coppenhall
Holiday dupes: Love Santorini? Try these Greek island alternatives FAQs
It depends on what you love about Santorini and what you want from your budget. Paros is worth considering for whitewashed Cycladic villages and a stylish atmosphere, Naxos for long sandy beaches and Milos for dramatic volcanic scenery. Crete and Rhodes also give you plenty of choice if you're happy to swap the classic Cycladic look for a different kind of Greek island holiday.
Not necessarily. Holiday prices vary depending on when you travel, where you stay and what's included. Rather than assuming Paros will cost less, compare similar holidays on both islands for your dates and look at what you're getting for your money.
If it’s Santorini’s Cycladic look you love, Paros, Naxos and Milos are all worth comparing. Each has its own character, though, so think about what you want most from your holiday, whether that’s pretty villages, sandy beaches or dramatic scenery.
May, June, September and October can be worth comparing with the July and August peak. Prices vary by island, hotel and departure date, so check the overall holiday rather than assuming travelling outside peak will always cost less.